The Toronto Blue Jays (24-17) and New York Yankees (24-19) will go head-to-head on Tuesday night in New York. New York earned a victory in Game One of the series. The Yankees are climbing the standings and have a chance to upset the MLB odds once again. New York is one of the best MLB teams in the league when they are playing well.

The Blue Jays have been a trustworthy pick when betting on baseball this season. Toronto is a talented ball club with a steady offense and an underrated pitching staff. They will make things interesting on Tuesday night.

First pitch is set for 7:07 PM EST on Tuesday night at Rogers Centre in Toronto, Canada. Let’s take a quick look at the Blue Jays vs Yankees prediction, stats, and the BetOnline baseball analysis.

TOP #3 Betting Sites to Bet on MLB

100% Crypto Bonus
Bonus Code “CRYPTO100”
1st Time Deposit
*with Cryptocurrencies
4.5 rating
T&Cs Apply
1st Time Crypto Bonus

If you have never made a deposit with Cryptocurrency before, use promo code CRYPTO100 on your first-ever deposit using either Bitcoin, Bitcoin Cash, Ethereum, Litecoin, Ripple, Stellar, or USD Coin, to earn a 100% Bonus.
Receive Up to:
50% 1st Deposit
Bonus Code “MYB50”
* Initial Deposit only. Maximum bonus awarded $1,000
4.8 rating
T&Cs Apply
Initial Deposit Only

We match 50% of your first deposit in Free Play. Use this industry leading welcome bonus to add more action to the games you love. Limited time only.
Bonus up to:
Welcome Bonus
* New users can get up to 150% bonus on their first deposit.
4.8 rating
T&Cs Apply
Please see BetNow's General Rules for additional Terms and Conditions, which apply to any and all promotions.

MLB Toronto Blue Jays at New York Yankees Betting Trends

  • The Toronto Blue Jays are 21-20 against the spread this season.
  • The New York Yankees are 23-20 against the spread this year. 
  • The Blue Jays are 8-8 against the spread at their home field.
  • The Yankees are 9-8 against the spread on the road.
  • Toronto is 14-15 against the spread at their home favorite.
  • New York is 8-5 against the spread as a road underdog.

How To Bet on Toronto Blue Jays at New York Yankees

The New York Yankees are underdogs in this game. The Yankees upset the odds Monday, and they fully expect to do the same on Tuesday.

New York is 20th in batting average, 22nd in OBP, 12th in slugging percentage, 10th in runs scored, and fifth in home runs.

Aaron Judge is heating up, and the Yankees’ stats are improving. New York’s offense still has some question marks, and they tend to rely on the long ball far too often.

That said, this offense has the potential to be a top-tier unit if they can stay healthy.

Pitching-wise, Domingo German (2-3, 4.00) gets the ball in the game. The Yankees are 13th in ERA, 10th in WHIP, 14th in home runs allowed, and fifth in batting average against.

German has certainly had his ups and downs. His presence on the mound will impact the Blue Jays vs Yankees prediction.

For the Blue Jays, they have had a strong season up to this point. They are eighth in batting average, sixth in OBP, 14th in slugging percentage, 10th in runs scored, and 16th in home runs.

This offense has been led by stars such as Vladimir Guerrero Jr, Bo Bichette, and Matt Chapman. The lineup hasn’t produced as much in the power department as expected, but the Yankees can’t take Toronto for granted nonetheless.

The Blue Jays’ pitching is 12th in ERA, 12th in WHIP, 20th in home runs allowed, and 11th in batting average against.

Kevin Gausman (2-3, 3.38) will get the ball for the Blue Jays. He’s been effective in 2023 and will try to help the Blue Jays earn a big victory at home in this Tuesday night affair.

Toronto Blue Jays at New York Yankees Betting Picks 

Which team should you place your money on? Will the Blue Jays be able to cover the odds at home, or can the Yankees upset the odds?

Toronto is going to have extra motivation after losing 7-4 at home on Monday. With Kevin Gausman on the hill, the Blue Jays will have confidence as well. 

The Yankees, though, are playing an impressive brand of baseball at the moment. New York managed to win three of their past four games and should give Toronto all they can handle. 

In the end, the Blue Jays are the best bet for Tuesday night. Toronto’s offense shouldn’t face too much trouble against German, while Gausman will take care of the rest.

Go ahead and roll with the Toronto Blue Jays with your Tuesday night betting selection as our Blue Jays vs Yankees prediction, in what projects to be a competitive affair between these American League East rivals.

Top Sportsbooks Odds

Betonline: Toronto Blue Jays -1.5

Bovada: Toronto Blue Jays -1.5

MyBookie: Toronto Blue Jays -1.5

BetUS: Toronto Blue Jays -1.5

BetNow: Toronto Blue Jays -1.5

Bonus! Other Games Worth Placing a Bet On 

Minnesota Twins at Los Angeles Dodgers

The Dodgers are favored at home against the Twins in this game. Los Angeles is the best team in the National League right now, and they haven’t displayed any signs of slowing down. The Twins are a solid ball club, but L.A. is the team to roll with. 

Take the Los Angeles Dodgers -1.5.

Philadelphia Phillies at San Francisco Giants

The Phillies are favored on the road against San Francisco. The Giants are in the midst of a forgettable year, while Philadelphia is looking to rebound from a difficult start to the season.

With Zack Wheeler on the mound for the Phillies, Philadelphia should be in line to get the job done.

Take the Philadelphia Phillies -1.5.

Kansas City Royals at San Diego Padres

Up to this point, we have only chosen favorites. However, Kansas City is a sneaky underdog MLB pick in this game.

San Diego is struggling, and young RHP Brady Singer gets the ball for KC in this game. Although Singer hasn’t had a good start in 2023, he was a breakout pitcher last year and features enough talent to keep the Royals in the contest.

Take the Kansas City Royals +1.5.

Cleveland Guardians at Chicago White Sox

The Cleveland Guardians will roll with Shane Bieber against a lackluster White Sox team. Cleveland, as a home favorite, is worth the bet in this one.

Take the Cleveland Guardians +1.5.

Check out the best betting sites to wager online at Online Betting Sports. Stay with us to keep up with the best offshore sportsbooks reviews and sports betting bonusesFollow us on Twitter.

Top Sportsbooks
4.5 rating
Betonline was already considered a platform with immense integrity, and as such, was trusted by bettors everywhere.
5.0 rating
BetUS is a Costa Rica based offshore sports betting company. Launched in 1994, it is one of the oldest sports betting sites in the world.
4.8 rating
Bovada is a trusted online gambling site offering sports betting, poker, casino games and betting on horse racing.
4.8 rating
MyBookie bonuses are some of the best in the business, both in terms of quality and variety. This is an area that put MyBookie up.
4.8 rating
In our review, emerges as a standout online sportsbook and casino. It offers an engaging betting experience where users can log in, place bets, and potentially reap significant rewards, distinguishing itself from the usual online sports betting platforms.
Top Casinos
5.0 rating
Experience the thrill of casino gaming from the comfort of your home with Vegas Aces. With a variety of popular games, secure withdrawal methods, and commitment to responsible gambling, Vegas Aces is your premier destination for a secure and enjoyable online casino experience.
5.0 rating
The Wild Casino is indeed living up to its name. The operators of this online casino didn't make a naming mistake, from the wild payouts to wild game offerings to fast gameplay.
5.0 rating
Slots Paradise casino is a new casino, but the operators are fantastic. It will soon be a big name in the betting industry committed to offering quality games to its players.
Online Betting Sports - Sports Betting Sites Reviews, Odds, News and Picks
© Copyright 2024 Online Betting Sports - Sports Betting Odds, News, Picks & Predictions